Fiona Cauley may be comedy’s best kept secret. Though through countless appearances on every major comedian’s podcast and program, including Theo Von, Mark Normand & Sam Morrill, The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon, and Kill Tony, Cauley may not be a secret for long. The hilariously honest wheelchair-bound comic has been wielding her unique brand of stand-up since her friends simply started calling her a comedian only a handful of years ago.
Though comedy wasn’t her first love, it was the medium that best equipped her to deal with her diagnosis of Friedreich’s Ataxia, a neuromuscular disorder which causes damage to the heart and nervous system. Cauley expertly offers both self-deprecating humor about her own condition and an extended hand to those in similar situations. Once in a while, a voice emerges that feels both fresh and familiar, like a friend you just can’t wait to have drinks with at the end of a hard day. Cauley is quickly becoming that friend to many who have discovered her comedy as well as her story.
I love your origin story. I love that you seemingly tried something on a whim, or sort of got volunteered really; you fell in love and it changed your whole trajectory. When you knew that comedy was your path, did you go all-in? Did you kinda do the whole “I’ll give it a year”?
Honestly, I never thought being a comedian was a job. I was like, “I don’t have any hobbies; I’ll do this for fun” and it just kept snowballing. It’s hard to make friends as adults, so I was like OK, I’m around people; we’re drinking and hanging out. It’s better than being around my friends, who can all walk. They wanna go to a dance club, and I’m staring at everyone’s butt. It was a better situation for me.
The comedian life does seem very freeing and fun. Not to oversimplify it, but you’re traveling with a mic and backpack and your skill is your voice.
It’s crazy. I think a lot about how weird comedy is. People are like, “I’m gonna (make) money off of one character trait that a lot of people have.”
Did you grow up a big comedy fan? Or did you have to sort of go to your research?
I always loved comedy shows and standup. I wouldn’t say I was more of a fanatic than your average funny friend. It’s not like I was obsessed. I didn’t have posters of Louis CK in my bedroom. I don’t know why I couldn’t think of another one from childhood (laughs). I love comedy, but I can’t say I did a lot of research. When I was just a consumer of comedy, it blows my mind; I’d buy tickets to see certain people. It’s crazy to me that I’m touring, and people are buying my tickets. I’m by no means mainstream.
As I prepared for this chat, I talked about you to so many people, and almost everyone knew who you were, or as soon as they pulled you up by name, they were like, “Oh yeah, I love her!”
That’s so sweet.
And in listening to your other interviews, I noticed it just got bigger and bigger. You were on We Might Be Drunk with Sam Morrill and Mark Normand, who are the first two comics I ever interviewed. Then I thought “Well, she probably hasn’t been on Theo Von.” Nope, you’ve been on Theo Von.
I keep worming my way into these situations.
Do you feel like you see a boost from stuff like Kill Tony, Theo Von etc? Do you see your followers go up? Do you see the impact?
Those two in particular, absolutely. Theo went way out of his way to be as kind as possible to me as far as just, like, helping me on tour. The day the podcast released, he posted my tour dates on his main page, like, thank you! There’s a huge crossover there now. I’ve opened for Nikki Glaser, people like that.
That’s huge. I was gonna ask you initially about Kill Tony, but you were on Andrew Santino’s podcast talking about how its weird when people sort of only bring up that appearance when you’ve been doing it for years already.
To be fair, credit where credit is due. I think a lot of people know me from there, but some think it was my first time doing comedy. Well, that is not true.
That’s what I thought initially. I don’t know why. It’s funny because you’re so good and polished. But I guess let people believe you’re just amazing right off the bat.
I just stay quiet. You’re gonna create a story, and I’m gonna let it be.
NNM: Do you have any favorite podcasts? What’s one you’ve done where you learned a lot?
I did Ryan Sickler’s podcast Honey Dew. That was one of my favorites. He’s a comedian too, obviously. It’s kind of a real talk podcast, getting to know each other. I see him as a father figure now. Andrew Santino, fantastic too. He’s been in the game so long, but he made me feel so comfortable, like an equal, and that was my first time meeting him.
Oh wow, that was your first meeting? He really goes after you (laughs). I thought you’d been friends a while.
I’d literally never met him. To me, when you’re OK making jokes or messing with me like I would with anyone else, that makes me feel equal, I guess, or seen. I don’t want people to go (easy) around me because I’m disabled. Just don’t go farther than I would (laughs).
I loved your TEDx talk. Even in the comedic world, it’s gotta be tough because it’s like, if one thing is off limits then everything is.
Right.
You had a quote, “Comedy made me feel more capable,” and you talked about finding your people. A lot of people don’t ever find their thing or even know it’s out there. It was cool to view something that could be considered just silly or mean turn out to be a lifesaver.
For real. Just trying to find value and why I’m here. I think we all question when something like this happens after you’re like, “I know what life is, I’m 18!” (laughs). This gave me purpose again.
How many years have you been at it now?
I think we’re approaching six. So I am a baby comedian technically. Any other comedian would wanna punch me for touring this soon (laughs). I like to say that six in wheelchair years is like 10 for ya’ll.
Have you encountered much pushback? Even though you really only joke about yourself, I imagine you still get some “you can’t joke about that.”
Yeah, but it’s never been from a disabled person (laughs). If it’s a disabled person, I’ll think about what I’m doing, but otherwise, I don’t care. There are people online that think I’m fully faking being disabled, which is a really interesting narrative.
Do you feel pressure use your platform?
Yeah, that’s a really good question. I don’t mean to talk about it, but it’s everything I do. My perspective on everything is from this seat, so naturally it’s become that. I’ve slowly become an advocate for my disease; that’s been really cool. I’m starting to think I’m doing more than just comedy. That’s a dream I didn’t know I could do.
I spoke with Drew Lynch recently, and I asked him if he ever saw a day where he didn’t talk about his stutter as much. Is that something you think about?
I’ve become more of a storyteller. I didn’t know until, like, a year and a half ago that you could just lie. But I don’t need to because the shit that’s happened in life is just do ridiculous that people already think I’m lying.
I used to just think every comedian had the funniest life ever.
Right! I had no idea they were just lying! That’s crazy! My set is not any different than other people. I talk about being a young woman; I talk about dating, bachelorette trips. I’m actually a very dark comedian. A lot of bad things have happened, and I have to laugh about them because I’m not in therapy (laughs).
Comedy is underrated when it comes to heavy topics. We’re so quick to say no, that’s not allowed; that’s over the line. The world is really hard right now, and to be able to throw on someone’s special and laugh for an hour is needed.
It’s never been more important.
How do you prep for something like Fallon versus Kill Tony? I assume you work that five minutes for a while beforehand.
That five minutes was in my hour set for about a year. When I found out they wanted me to do that bit, there’s actually a different ending to it that I had to clean up for TV.
The lady at the airport bit?
Yeah, honestly, it was just not cussing. I had to change certain words and the way I said things. The night before you do it on Fallon, you run the set twice in front of his booker at The Cellar. That was some practice. All day that day, I was not cussing because I was trying to get it out of my brain. At the end of the set, normally Fallon plugs tour dates or whatever, and I asked if he would plug CureFA.org, which is where you donate to research for Friedreich’s Ataxia. I didn’t know it was a big deal, that no one had ever done that. It meant so much that Jimmy was, like, willing to break the mold in that way.
How do you prefer to write? Do you have a favorite place or setting?
This is gonna piss you off dude (laughs). I can’t sit down and just say “I’m writing for an hour.” I think I write on stage a lot. I’ll wake up in the middle of the night and jot something down I thought of in a dream. I’ve never sat down and said, “We’re gonna write about the airport today.”
What’s something that’s been inspiring you lately? It could be another comic, a TV show, an album. What’s getting you excited creatively?
I just finished the show Hacks. Holy shit it’s so good. I love shows about being a comedian, but it’s not necessarily about comedy but the grind to get somewhere. It’s inspiring and entertaining. I’m trying to think. Unfortunately, I don’t have much time to do things besides comedy these days. I’m fortunate my husband is a comedian and tours with me.
You don’t have a partner where you can say “What’d you do at your normal job today?” Do you ever get burned out?
We have not gotten burned out yet. It’s nice to have someone who knows that comedy is an addiction. You don’t turn it off at any point. My favorite thing is, when we do argue, if one of us says something funny, we’ll pause the argument to write it down.
Then fight about who gets to take it.
Literally! But I’m like “I came up with this!” And he’s like, “but the punchline is mine!”

Follow her official site and Instagram @fionacauley, or donate to Friedreich’s Ataxia research here.
Photos courtesy of Fiona Cauley



